The New Jersey Tide
Sandy Hook to Cape May, every day.
← Atlantic County
CourtsAtlantic County

Atlantic City man pleads guilty to handgun and criminal mischief charges

Jeffrey Hall, 40, faces a recommended five-year state prison term. Prosecutors are appealing a judge's decision to release him before sentencing.

An Atlantic City man has pleaded guilty to second-degree unlawful possession of a handgun and fourth-degree criminal mischief, prosecutors said Monday.

Jeffrey Hall, 40, entered the plea Oct. 14 before Superior Court Judge Christine Smith. Under the plea agreement, prosecutors will recommend a five-year state prison sentence, with three and a half years to be served before he is eligible for parole.

The gun charge stems from July 28, 2025, when Atlantic City police responded to a 911 call that was hung up, with the sounds of a fight audible in the background, according to prosecutors. A woman told dispatchers that a man, later identified as Hall, was armed with a gun, was chasing her and was hiding the weapon in a green bag, prosecutors said.

Hall had left by the time officers arrived, but police found him a short time later near Pennsylvania and Reading avenues, prosecutors said. He matched the description the woman had given and had a green bag with him, which he told police was his. Officers found a revolver inside, and Hall did not have a permit to carry it, according to prosecutors.

The criminal mischief charge stems from April 20, when police were called to a report of a man breaking a door and refusing to leave a home, prosecutors said. A woman told police that Hall had kicked in her front door and gone inside, and officers saw broken trim at the bottom of the door, according to prosecutors. Hall had left before police arrived.

After the plea, Smith granted a defense request to release Hall until sentencing over prosecutors' objection, and denied their request to put that order on hold, prosecutors said. Superior Court Judge Pamela D'Arcy, the presiding judge for criminal cases, later granted the stay. The decision to release Hall is now before the Appellate Division, according to prosecutors.

This brief was drafted by AI from a public agency’s press release and published by The New Jersey Tide. Why we use AI for stories like this one.

Filed underCourtsAtlantic County